Reynolds Paradise – Key West, Florida, United States

Hosted by Alison

2 months hosting on Houfy

Identity verified

This host verified their email and phone number on Houfy.

Accepts payments on Houfy

This host allows you to book through Houfy.

Pets are allowed

Book Direct and Save

Save on service fees by booking direct on Houfy.

Ask AI about this propertyBeta

Or message Alison · responds in within an hour

About this place

Reynolds Paradise | Walk to Higgs Beach

Welcome to Reynolds Paradise, a beautifully renovated island retreat designed for relaxation, comfort, and unforgettable stays.

This spacious 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom home comfortably sleeps up to 8 guests with a sofa sleeper and a daybed with trundle, making it perfect for two couples, families, or small groups traveling together.

Inside, you'll find abundant natural light, central air conditioning, and an open, airy layout with plenty of room to spread out. The fully updated chef's kitchen features an island with seating and everything you need to prepare meals at home. Newly renovated bathrooms include two spacious walk in showers for a spa-like experience.

Step outside into your own private tropical oasis. Unwind in the jacuzzi hot tub, enjoy meals under the covered outdoor dining area, or relax on the expansive deck within the fully fenced backyard. An outdoor shower makes it easy to rinse off after a day in the sun, while the washer and dryer add extra convenience for longer stays. Guests will also appreciate the convenience of off-street parking, a rare amenity in Key West.

Whether you're looking for a peaceful getaway, a family vacation, or a comfortable home base for exploring the area, Reynolds Paradise offers the perfect blend of indoor luxury and outdoor island living.

What this place offers

27 Amenities

Washing Machine

Iron & Board

Hair Dryer

Linens Provided

Full Kitchen

Oven

Hot Tub

Patio

High Speed Internet

Smart TV

Smoke Detector

First Aid Kit

Nearby activities

14 Activities

Jet skiing

Deepsea fishing

Pier fishing

Wind surfing

Golf

Cycling

Swimming

Fly fishing

Property Suitability

Please review these important guidelines to ensure this property meets your needs and expectations.

Child friendly

No events allowed

No smoking allowed

Parking Included

Meet the Host

Alison

Host

English

Alison Costello is the founder of Welcome Home Key West and Welcome Home Charlevoix, where she combines her professional hospitality experience with her genuine love for creating beautiful, welcoming places to stay. A longtime Key West resident and a proud Michigander with deep roots in Northern Michigan, Alison considers both Key West and Charlevoix home. Her love for travel, great food and wine, animals, and discovering the little things that make a destination special is reflected in the homes she manages and the experiences she creates for guests. Outside of work, Alison is a mom, animal lover, and self proclaimed foodie and wine enthusiast. She loves exploring local restaurants, spending time with family, being on the water, and finding new places and experiences to share with others. Through Welcome Home, Alison brings a personal touch to vacation rental management, combining professional hospitality with the kind of local knowledge and attention to detail that comes from genuinely loving the places she calls home. Whether you're visiting Key West for sunshine and island life or Charlevoix for lake days, small town charm, and Northern Michigan summers, Alison hopes to make your stay feel a little more like coming home.

Member Since

August 2026