Sunset Beach on Seneca Lake 5BR Retreat Pool&Dock image 1
Sunset Beach on Seneca Lake 5BR Retreat Pool&Dock image 2
Sunset Beach on Seneca Lake 5BR Retreat Pool&Dock image 3
Enjoy the sunset from the end of the dock!
Sunset Beach house, relax on the porch and take in the great lake views!

Sunset Beach on Seneca Lake 5BR Retreat Pool&Dock

5 bedrooms·3 baths
Ovid • New York
4.98(100 reviews)

$1,676.67 USD total for 3 nights

Nov 3 – 6, 2026

Welcome to Captain's Quarters
Escape to Keuka Lake
Captain's Quarters on the waterfront, 3 bedrooms/1 bath
Captain's Quarters: Farmhouse dining table for 8
Captain's Quarters: Spacious eat-in kitchen area

Captain's Quarters | Keuka | Hot Tub | Kayak/SUPs

3 bedrooms·1 bath
Penn Yan • New York

$1,449.00 USD total for 3 nights

Nov 3 – 6, 2026

Enjoy the evening sunset down by the lake
Cayuga lake cottage with private lake access
Cayuga lake cottage with private lake access
Cayuga lake cottage with private lake access
Cayuga lake cottage with private lake access

Cayuga lake cottage with private lake access

2 bedrooms·1 bath
Lansing • New York

$916.30 USD total for 3 nights

Nov 3 – 6, 2026

O'Cottage Keuka Lake Vacation Rental-updated
O'Cottage Keuka Lake Vacation Rental-updated
O'Cottage Keuka Lake Vacation Rental-updated
O'Cottage Keuka Lake Vacation Rental-updated
O'Cottage Keuka Lake Vacation Rental-updated

O'Cottage Keuka Lake Vacation Rental-updated

4 bedrooms·1 bath
Keuka Park • New York
4.33(6 reviews)

$2,730.00 USD total for 3 nights

Nov 3 – 6, 2026

Full wall of windows to enjoy the beautiful Cayuga Lake view!
Living Room with views out to the lake front.
Hot tub oasis overlooking the gorgeous lake view!
Aerial view of the sanctuary!
The backyard gives ample space for activities, has a fire pit for campfires, and is right next to Cayuga Lake!

Sanctuary On Cayuga | Waterfront Home | Hot Tub

6 bedrooms·3 baths
Cayuga • New York
4.97(35 reviews)

$2,806.00 USD total for 3 nights

Nov 3 – 6, 2026

Fingerlakes farm with goats & chickens
Fingerlakes farm with goats & chickens
Fingerlakes farm with goats & chickens
Fingerlakes farm with goats & chickens
Fingerlakes farm with goats & chickens

Fingerlakes farm with goats & chickens

3 bedrooms·2 baths
Auburn • New York

$773.80 USD total for 3 nights

Nov 3 – 6, 2026

Keuka Waterfront Cottage*WiFi*Beach Area
Keuka Waterfront Cottage*WiFi*Beach Area
Keuka Waterfront Cottage*WiFi*Beach Area
Keuka Waterfront Cottage*WiFi*Beach Area
Keuka Waterfront Cottage*WiFi*Beach Area

Keuka Waterfront Cottage*WiFi*Beach Area

2 bedrooms·1 bath
Pulteney • New York
5(19 reviews)

$1,151.26 USD total for 3 nights

Nov 3 – 6, 2026

“Waterfront Retreat w/ Private Bar • Walkout Yard image 1
“Waterfront Retreat w/ Private Bar • Walkout Yard image 2
“Waterfront Retreat w/ Private Bar • Walkout Yard image 3
“Waterfront Retreat w/ Private Bar • Walkout Yard image 4
“Waterfront Retreat w/ Private Bar • Walkout Yard image 5

“Waterfront Retreat w/ Private Bar • Walkout Yard

5 bedrooms·3 baths
Cayuga County • New York
5(1 review)

$2,350.00 USD total for 3 nights

Nov 3 – 6, 2026

Welcoming retreat! Situated on 5.6 acres and backing to Cornell natural research lands, you'll enjoy the sights and sounds of all sorts of wildlife. Binoculars available!
Long gravel driveway provides privacy, yet only a mile from shopping/dining.
Front house view; house is a tenth of a mile back from the road for privacy, six minutes to shopping/dining, and ten minutes to downtown & Cornell.
Spacious living room with skylights and vaulted ceiling
Living room pic 2

Cherry Road Retreat

3 bedrooms·2½ baths
Ithaca • New York
5(33 reviews)

$1,480.50 USD total for 3 nights

Dec 3 – 6, 2026

Cayuga Hideaway image 1
Cayuga Hideaway image 2
Cayuga Hideaway image 3
Cayuga Hideaway image 4
Cayuga Hideaway image 5

Cayuga Hideaway

2 bedrooms·1 bath
Auburn • New York
$200 – $225/ night(excl. fees & taxes)