New Listing! Secluded Large Modern home on Indian Hill Road
Hosted by Norman
Registration ID: C0038373270
Identity verified
This houfie verified their email and phone number on Houfy.
Pets are allowed
Pets Considered


Newly completed last year, this stunning colonial home in West Tisbury is fully equipped with all the modern amenities in an open floor plan with plenty of space for all. "Sunnyside" is located in a very private and quiet 4.3-acre wooded compound. The Main House is sited on top of a tall hill and above the surrounding countryside. It is surrounded by mature beech and oak trees giving it the feeling of a treehouse, open to the breezes that blow through the trees.

Enjoy the gourmet kitchen with top of the line LG appliances. The large kitchen island with comfortable seating is perfect for interacting with your friends and family while you prepare a delicious meal. The furnishings were professionally selected and are by Restoration Hardware. They grace and complement each room perfectly. This four-level home can take a crowd and also be comfortable for a couple or two that want their own private spaces. These include a lovely front porch with seating, a back deck, a large side porch covered in cedar, a kitchen peninsula with seating for 6 and a garden level game and media room.

The home has central air conditioning that's controllable from every level as well as smart home technology to make managing the heat, cooling and lights and environment effortless.

The main home presents as new after a complete top to bottom renovation. There are all new walls, floors, windows, doors, and appliances.
The large open first floor has a wonderful kitchen island seating area, living room, and dining area.
The second floor features a master suite and two large bedrooms.
The third floor is wide open and ready for anything.
The Garden Level features a game room, ping pong table and pull out sofa bed.

The entire property incorporates the following buildings

THE MAIN HOUSE - SLEEPS 10+ [5 bed 4 bath]
GUEST COTTAGE - SLEEPS 8+ [4 bed 2 bath] (not available until June 2021)
FAMILY COMPOUND add the two houses together (not available until June 2021)

We are happy to have events but you will need to apply for written permission. Depending on the event you may need a fee, security deposit, and event insurance.


This elegant and luxurious home is located in West Tisbury on the beautiful island of Marthas Vineyard. It is located off of desirable Indian Hill Road near Arrowhead Farm. This large equestrian center is open to the public. The property is also just down the road from Cedar Tree Neck, one of the island's most beautiful walking trail systems. You are also near the world-famous Polly Hill Arboretum and of course the fantastic Lambert's Cove Beach. There is an available 11 passenger van with a beach sticker as well.

We are also just five miles west of the Vineyard Haven Ferry Terminal and seven miles northwest of the Martha's Vineyard Airport, allowing you to easily reach the house no matter how you arrive. The beautiful shores of Lambert's Cove Beach are two miles north, and the many attractions of downtown Oak Bluffs - from the historic Flying Horses to Inkwell Beach - are eight miles east. Edgartown is a short drive down the Edgartown road where there are ample public parking and transportation options. You can even ride your bike there through the State Forest.

Owner is a license Florida RE sales associate - not licensed in Massachusetts. I own another property in Edgartown called the Captain Morse House. This is available for rent and for sale as well.
Show More


Washing Machine
Clothes Dryer
Air Conditioning
Full Kitchen
Cable TV
Security Cameras
Smoke Detector

Seasonal Pricing

Minimum stayPer nightWeekend nightsPer weekPer month
Base price

Reviews (1)

Excellent based on 1 Review


Child friendly
Crib/Pack 'n Play
Parking Included
Lots of parking
Wheelchair Accessible
We will need to discuss this. Ramps can be built.

Getting around

There are lots of great cabs on the island. We are also a walkable distance from the market and the bus stop at Cronig's up island grocery store.

Location & Views



These directions are for planning purposes only. You may find that construction projects, traffic, weather, or other events may cause conditions to differ from the map results, and you should plan your route accordingly. You must obey all signs or notices regarding your route.
Check in
Check out
Add date
Add date
1 guest
Enter dates and number of guests to check the total trip price, including additional fees and any taxes.
Report this listing


Property Manager
I own and manage several rental properties. I grew up on the vineyard and spent my summers there until I graduated from college. Now I come back every spring and fall to work on the property.
Our main rental property is the Captain Morse House in Edgartown. This property has been in our family since 1955.
In 2017 we bought Indian Hill Road as a flip and then promptly made a classic mistake. We over improved the property. Because of this it will be hard to sell so we have decided to rent it out. The island has a shortage of good quality rentals and we think that this will rent well. Both of our properties have 5 star reviews.

Indian Hill Road was a brand new project for us. It is quite a home and we are proud to be able to share it with you.
We had one very successful (5 star review!) rental for the main house in 2019. The cottage we rented out for the first time long term (18 months) to a young couple. They are moving out June 1st. Those successful rentals have encouraged us to put the house on the rental market for this coming season.

My own background:
I grew up in the Captain Morse House in Edgartown and spent my summers there until I graduated from college. The Captain Morse House was purchased by my father the year I was born and was used by our family exclusively until 2008.

Prior to managing property I owned and ran Island Sports from 1974 until 2007 with my wife Nancy. I have built several homes and done numerous renovations. I enjoy the challenge of creating wonderful living spaces. I am now a Realtor in Southern Florida but really spend most of my time working on these rental properties.
If you are interested in purchasing either of these properties or in Real Estate Management or representation please send me an inquiry

Due to my on island experience I can help you craft the best possible vacation. I can provide the best possible service when we communicate via telephone or email.
Read more
Phone:Click to show +1 508-627-4895
Email:Click to show info@captainmorsehouse.com
Houfy lets you contact and book direct with hosts. The host has provided the following links to give you more information.

Policies and Rules

Check In: Flexible
Check Out: Flexible
Suitable for Events
With written permission. We need to know all about the event to approve it.
No smoking
Refundable Damage Deposit
Returned within 30 days after your rental. Ask about our damage insurance.
© Norman and Houfy Inc. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this page's author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Norman and Houfy Inc. with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.
For more information, please visit the Houfy's copyright and trademark policy

Indian Hill Road Main House is a Vacation Home located in West Tisbury, Massachusetts, United States. This Vacation Home is available for short term lodging and accommodates 16 guests
Indian Hill Road Main House has 5 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms and was listed on Houfy on Apr 2020

Listing # 14736 - 53 Views

List your
  • Vacation home
  • Apartment
  • Condo
  • Property
for free on Houfy
Listing your property can take as little as a few minutes to complete – get started today